I’ve had this book in my “to read” pile for years, and never gotten around to it. Yay! said I, when I heard there would be a TV adaptation. I can decide if I like the story enough to read the book! The answer: nope.
I’m not sure if it’s the plot or the production, but it just felt totally lackluster. Stephen is an Englishman who meets and falls for the married Isabelle, and she for him. World War I intervenes, and Stephen has a miserable time in the trenches. The two find each other again, but are ultimately parted by Random Issues That Would Never Really Keep Anyone Apart. This all (minus the ending) sounds okay, right? But it’s just a big ball of MEH. Neither Redmayne nor Poesy give an inspired performance, and their characters are relatively spineless and annoying. Visually, it’s fine, but the costumes are very “Hey! We’re casual people wearing modern clothes!” That’s not to say I think they should be dressing like the Tsar/Tsarina of Russia, just that there are ways to make middle class clothing interesting, but the costumer doesn’t do so here.
My rating: 1 (out of 5)
If you like this era, you might also want to check my Edwardian Costume Movie Reviews. I specifically recommend the following World War I costume movies: Downton Abbey (2010) and The Winslow Boy (1999). If you’re down with the cheese, then I also recommend In Love and War (1996).
What did you think? Have you watched it, and if so, did Redmayne/Poesy annoy you to death? Do you remember any of the costumes?
The rocket dress from Marie Antoinette (1938), designed by Adrian and conserved at LACMA.
I didn’t take very many pictures while I was making the dress, because I wasn’t blogging about it and I was focused on just getting it done! But I did take a few photos that show a bit of the process, plus I’ve finally gotten the official con photos of the outfit, and I gotta post those!
Here's a crappy early evening/outdoor photo of the pannier from the back.
I used Simplicity 3635 — I know! — for the pannier. I looked at the diagrams in Norah Waugh’s Corsets & Crinolines and Jean Hunnisett’s Period Costume for Stage & Screen, and found that they were really similar. The only real tweak I made to the Simplicity pattern is that I put boning in the bottom hoop. If you look at the pattern image, you’ll see the pattern breaks off around mid-calf, which I think would look really ugly underneath a skirt! Plus, I’m 5’11”, and I can use all the length I can get.
Because I am cheap and couldn’t stomach the thought of paying for all that hoop wire, I ended up using 3/8″ half-round caning from the Caning Shop, which was super cheap! I was, however, terrified that it would break, particularly when packing the giant hoop o’ doom into the car for the drive down to Costume College. So I ended up doubling the cane in each casing, which worked out great in terms of supports — no cracking, breaking, etc. One thing I did that you may want to avoid, however, is I initially thought that the half-round cane should go into the casing flat side to flat side, so that it would make one whole round — I thought a flat side against curved side might lay weird. Well, I found that the cane wants to go around with its natural bend, and when you put the second piece in flat to flat, you’ve got one piece of cane that is trying to bend against its natural curve — and things go wonky! It didn’t curve nicely and ended up sort of warped looking. So I pulled it out and put it back in, flat side to round side, both pieces curving along their natural curve, and it all laid fine and made a lovely shape.
A super crappy shot of the base skirt.
I wasn’t sure whether I’d need a petticoat to avoid the individual hoops sticking out, but I decided to make the skirt first and see if I needed one. I made a base skirt of grey cotton, because in looking at the original dress, I misread the top lace swags as a separate piece, not just applied swags like the lower pieces. I used Katherine/Koshka’s 18th c. court skirt tutorial to start, although I had to do a lot of futzing to get the end pleats to hang where I wanted them. It was REALLY hard to level the skirt given that my dress form was a floor model and so has a decided lean and rickety-ness to it! I ended up marking one side, and then matching the other side to those markings, and crossing my fingers.
The pannier/skirt was SO huge, I had to move it all into the living room while I was working on it. Luckily my husband was out of town for about 5 days, so I was able to take over! Unfortunately, the dogs discovered the joys of “I hide under the skirt and get you,” so I had to swat them away. A lot.
(C) Andrew Schmidt, http://photos.theshotwellcollection.com/
I attached the satin skirt to the cotton underskirt. The base of the satin goes up to about where the hoop starts to go down rather than out. The cotton underskirt and upper satin skirt are all sewn into the same waistband.
The lace around the overskirt is cut from that same yardage and hemmed. I made the flowers from the same satin, after trying to find some vintage silver flowers (no dice) or modern fabric flowers that weren’t cheesy (ditto).
A crappy shot of the bodice in progress (crappy photos seem to be a theme here!)
This is the only in-progress photo I took of the bodice, which is very Victorian in approach. I tried to follow the lace layout on the original, cutting motifs out of the lace yardage I had and hand sewing them to the bodice.
(C) Andrew Schmidt, http://photos.theshotwellcollection.com/
The bodice closure uses the technique found in most 18th c. court dresses, where the bodice and lining are separate for about 1-2″ along the center back. Lacing holes are put into the lining layer, and therefore don’t show through the fashion fabric.
Makeup test #1: Kryolan Aquacolor in white
I did a number of makeup tests with Leia, which didn’t start off too well. We read a number of posts on Cosplay.com, and most everyone recommended Kryolan Aquacolor. Although we planned to use grey, I had some white on hand that I messed with… and I swear, anything more than the first layer seen above made me look like I was covered in calamine lotion. NOT good. And one layer left a lot of pink showing through.
Makeup test #2: Kryolan Supracolor in white mixed with black
Luckily there’s a Kryolan store here in San Francisco, so I went in for help, and they showed me Supracolor, which is an oil-based makeup and therefore SO easy to apply! It goes on smooth and moist, and you can mix colors easily on your skin or beforehand (I mixed white with black to get grey), and it’s very moveable until you set it with powder and setting spray. The rest of my makeup I did with standard makeup — grey and white eyeshadows and a grey eyeliner. I’m a lip balm addict, and was REALLY worried about putting something drying on my lips and having to not touch it all night. I ended up covering my lips thickly with my usual lip balm, and then coloring over that with the grey eyeliner, which actually made a bit of a lipstick-y paste… and I managed to go all night without wanting to rip my lips off and dunk them in a bath of Burt’s Bees, which is saying something! (Come on, fellow lip balm addicts, you know you feel me).
Detail from a photo (C) Andrew Schmidt, http://photos.theshotwellcollection.com/
I was super excited about my jewelry. The necklace is FABULOUS and, shockingly, came from H&M a year or so ago, a present from the fabulous Trystan. A couple of people asked about the matching rhinestone bracelets I wore, which were dirt cheap (like $4-5 each with free shipping!) from Alilang on Ebay. And this was the first wearing of my SUPER-EXCITED-ABOUT QVC Marie Antoinette earrings, which are amazing reproductions of a real pair of Marie Antoinette’s earrings, conserved at the Smithsonian.
And lastly, a few more official photos!
(C) Andrew Schmidt, http://photos.theshotwellcollection.com/(C) Andrew Schmidt, http://photos.theshotwellcollection.com/
I signed up for Pinterest a while ago, but hadn’t done anything with it until I read some interesting discussion this weekend on Livejournal about how it can be useful for getting the word out about things you love, especially fellow costumers and their creations!
So I’ve been dabbling a bit — mostly pinning modern fashion/sewing ideas, which is something I collect haphazardly and then frequently forget about.
But I also added a board of Favorite Costumes: reproduction historical costumes made by fabulous costumers! It’s a work in progress, but I’m excited about being able to give props to the costumes you all make that I love.
For years I’ve heard about Exclusive Buttons, a brick and mortar-only vintage button shop in El Cerrito (San Francisco Bay Area – East Bay). I used to live relatively close to them, but never made it by during their limited opening hours. A few weeks ago the husband and I were noodling around that area, and I finally remembered to pop in!
The store is run by the widow of a gentleman who used to run a business selling buttons to stores (out of his van) since the 1960s. At some point they stopped the wholesale button business and opened a retail shop. He has since passed on, but his wife is still running the shop.
The shop is small but FILLED to the brim with all kinds of vintage buttons. The only modern buttons they stock are Czech glass, and the owner proudly told me that there are no plastic buttons anywhere in their shop (okay, except things like Lucite). The prices are CRAZY good; the owner told me she hasn’t updated the prices since her husband passed.
I didn’t go in looking for anything too specific, so I just wandered and grabbed what caught my eye. Here’s a few pictures, plus my haul:
What I bought: green gingham buttons (in the plastic bag), some random green buttons, belt buckle that’s actually more pink than red, a bunch of red buttons, and a self-covered belt buckle form. When the owner saw I was buying the buckle form, she threw in some vintage belting for free!
Thanks SO much to everyone who gave me your feedback on the idea of an 18th century hair/wig-styling book! I got a TON of positive, useful feedback and I really think it’s viable, so I am going to go for it!
I’m still crunching the data I gathered on the survey, and exploring options for images. I’ve ordered myself a practice mannequin so I can work out the specific styles I want to do.
And there are some things I want to do a bit more research on, like caps — how ubiquitous were they? Etc.
I even appreciate those who said they WOULDN’T buy the book, because that’s helpful to know! It seems like those few are more interested in a book on 18th century techniques, which I agree are interesting, but I just don’t see myself (or the bulk of costumers/theater people) wanting to make pomade out of beef tallow and setting curls by baking hair on clay curlers in ovens. It just doesn’t sound viable. I’ll certainly be researching how they did it, and including information about that in the book.
~~~
My goal is to have the book ready to go for Costume College 2013!
And — what I’m going to do is use Kickstarter, which is a site that allows people to fund a project. You can donate $1 or $500, depending on the various levels that I set it at. Obviously I will have the basic “donation” be a discounted price on the book, and you’ll get a copy of the book at this discounted rate for pre-funding the project. This way I can figure out the cost of the book and essentially pre-sell it… And the way Kickstarter works is that you figure out what your funding goal is, and if you don’t make that goal, nobody’s credit cards get charged — so basically you’d be buying the book, but if for any reason I can’t get enough people to buy a copy and the project falls through, you wouldn’t be out a cent.
So my plan is do more research and figure out hairstyles over the next couple of months, and hopefully do the real work with photography and writing over winter/spring. I won’t start the Kickstarter pre-sale until I have things pretty firmly lined up with a finish date — so when a lot of the writing is done and I’m starting to work with models, and have a firm end date in site. So, watch this space for lots more updates!